maria / angelina

Why am I so put off by the idea of watching Angelina Jolie play Maria Callas in Pablo Larrain’s new ‘sumptuous’ bio-pic, Maria?

It’s strange, because I find Jolie mesmerizing. She strikes me as being a genuine weirdo – which I totally relate to : a unique actress – who else could have played the psycho-slippery female version of Cuckoo’s -Nest-Jack Nicholson in ‘Girl, Interrupted’, for which she won the Oscar for best supporting actress? This was a character whose IQ was so through the roof she essentially no longer knew how to exist. It was over-acting – if you want to look at it that way – but the ingestible craziness ate the screen. She was incredible in Gia, where she played a drug-addicted model. I like her in action films like Salt, and especially in the hyper-violent Wanted, which she nailed. She was very good in Clint Eastwood’s Changeling, even if the spotlight was stolen from her rather ruinously by her own lipstick (in a sepia film, yes her lips are to die for I realize, and I do love red lipstick – but mamma mia, ‘Chanel, sorry Guerlain Rouge A Levres’ should have been credited as the co-star). Her directing, in my opinion, is underrated – both Unbreakable, about Japanese atrocities in World War II, and First They Killed My Father, about the horrors committed by the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia, were solid, earnest, affecting, if occasionally heavy-handed films, even if her disastrous self-directed ‘divorce drama’ starring her very self and her ex-husband and now sworn enemy, Brad Pitt was literally unwatchable (when Brad starts ‘speaking French’……..my goodness…… )

I also respect and like Chilean director Pablo Larrain. Maria is the third film in his trilogy of Famous But Rather Troubled Twentieth Century Women – my subtitle, not his – the others being Jackie, where the divine Natalie Portman did a pretty good job of inhabiting the supposedly icy Onassis in the post Kennedy shooting era – the blood-soaked shirt was unforgettable, but the fact that I liked it didn’t surprise me; as most Black Narcissi know rather too well, I am now, and will forever, be obsessed with Ms Portman because of her role as Nina Sayers in the magnificent Black Swan, my piece on which is probably the most emotional and torrid you will ever get from me. I can’t see a picture of her now, even in some standardized pink Dior poster, without getting a micro-pang in the heart and stomach.

What surprised me far more was how much I loved Kristen Stewart as Princess Diana in the second part of the trilogy, ‘Spencer’. I find that Kristen’s overly-self-conscious lip-biting and general twitchery to denote ‘thinking’ and ‘feeling’ can sometimes work against her – she was atrocious in David Cronenberg’s Crimes Of The Future, like an AI android programmed to act like Kristen Stewart (or perhaps that was the entire point, and I missed it?). I thought the nervous energy she always brings to the table was just right in Personal Shopper, a ghost story about a fashion assistant flitting between London and Paris and a film I adore; and though I didn’t believe for a second that she was Jean Seberg, she looked so utterly beautiful in that film with her blonde crop and cut off tops – and it was so well crafted as a whole- that I didn’t remotely care.

But Princess Di? I suppose we Brits have a thing about others doing bad posh English accents. Some have still not got over Dick Van Dyke’s cockney in Mary Poppins – though it’s now obviously a one of a kind classic (and me and D often sing it at karaoke).. And Keanu Reeves in Bram Stoker’s Dracula, whose astonishingly absymal mauling of an upper class English voice is indescribable……………… comes full circle, in the end, and suits the high campery of the entire proceedings (oh my god, Lucy writhing in the garden…..) Eventually you wouldn’t want it any other way. In general, though, perhaps because I am an English teacher, I am overly sensitive to these things. A bad accent usually means a bad film for me. Some can nail it perfectly; Emma Stone can for sure; she was Britisher than British in Poor Things and The Favourite; I think Julianne Moore is pretty good; I love Nicole Kidman but I often think there is an Australian undertone to whatever accent she is trying out, whether American or British – her lurching into proper Aussie in the otherwise brilliant Portrait Of A Lady by Jane Campion really took you out of the action in what was otherwise an exquisitely overwrought film; one moment you thought you were in eighteenth century London, then you suddenly found yourself in Crocodile Dundee. Gillian Anderson can obviously do both because she is both British and American – although D walked in one day while I was watching The Crown – a series I thought was superlative in the extreme but which he couldn’t abide – we do have our differences; I can do more mainstream than he can – and he stood open mouthed, flabbergasted by the horrendousness of Anderson’s wheezing, sidewalking hairsprayed crustacean impression ofThatcher which had us both collapsing into hysterics (and for which she obviously won a lot of prestigious awards…I am usually out of sync with what ‘Academies’ etc considers to be good acting). The opposite is obviously also true with American accents, of course. You can’t take the Hermione out of Emma Watson. Michael Caine has never even tried. My hairs stand on end every time I see a Brit – particularly Daniel Craig – who I like otherwise attempt to do a classic Southern Drawl – but you know better than me so do tell me otherwise..

Anyway. I couldn’t for a second imagine Kristen Stewart, she who was so perfect as a moody, and very American teenager in the Twilight Series, madly in love with a blood-addicted but deliberately appetite suppressing vampire Robert Pattison – becoming British royalty. And my mother’s shackles were definitely raised to cushion-chewing levels one night, brother and father gone to bed, as we turned down the lights, opened up another bottle of red, while my sister, D and I settled down on the sofa one evening to watch the Diana bio-pic at my parent’s house. I love cinematic debates – it fascinates me how easily opinions differ, even with close friends whose taste is so often similar to yours; my friend Peter and I often sit agog at the other’s praises and dismissals; He liked The House Of Gucci; D and I both thought it was beyond dreadful – Gaga’s accent, porca miseria, D even slunk off to bed rather than continue the sufferance of watching it – which is quite an extreme blip of politeness for him but I suppose his taste membranes had just been too ingloriously busted; I myself eventually got into some of the bald-headed gilded ridiculousness of it all by the end (but really, just give the Sopranos or Godfather). Strangely, M3GAN, the camp as Christmas horror movie – my entire favourite of last year, but which Peter didn’t especially adhere to, whereas I saw it twice in the cinema – was an 80% family success; it thoroughly hooked in my dad, who loved the intricacies of the narrative and immediately declared he wanted to see it again; my brother, who was roaring thumping the armchair in approval several times, and my sister, who was shrieking in uninhibited delight with me and D all cackling in delirium and who later declared she was going to order a Megan poster for her house the next day. (Mum thought it was stupid, which it kind of is.)

But I digress! A few tassles were chewed during ‘Spencer’, and I think she reached its conclusion – but I can’t be sure. D, my sister Deborah, and I were somewhat transported by it, though. Stewart nailed the essence. The whole was so fragile and beautiful. The score by Radiohead’s Jonny Greenwood made it even better. And what I love about Larrain’s films is the subversion of the usual ultrapredictable character arc: the overexposition and beginning, the problem to be resolved and then the conclusion, all the principles of basic screenwriting which in truth have never interested me past about the age of three. I don’t NEED that. I just want to be SUSPENDED in something, to lose myself in a different time and place. And boy were we suspended. I could feel the physical and emotional coldness of The Palace as they all ‘holidayed’ up in Scotland, freezing Diana out. She felt convincingly, and tragically, alone. She captured that. You were in the mid-beginnings of her downward spiral. ‘Atmospheric’ doesn’t begin to hint at how full the film is with re-memorable period ambience- to me every detail, perfect; even the slightly off kilter fish eye lens of a South American director putting his own spin on things so classically British made it all feel slightly odd; renewed, and therefore more real, when so many period dramas, to me, just feel like a trip to the taxidermist’s. When Diana just can’t take any more of the stuffiness of The Firm, and recklessly drives her two young sons to a fast food restaurant to a backdrop of Mike And The Mechanics’ All I Need Is A Miracle – I was in heaven; it was so heartlifting and beautiful, despite the awful tragedy you know is going to happen not so far into the future…..

Yes, Larrain likes his tragic divas and socialites. All of whom had fine taste in scent, by the way. Jackie liked the sophisticatedly dirty – Bal A Versailles, Jicky; Joy, 1000 – I love the idea of her crêping past the crowds coolly and defiantly in the original Patou 1000 extrait – so alluring, so dignified, so superb in every respect; Krigler Patchouli – apparently a very straight up but deep New York patchouli I have never experienced but can imagine being adeptly prickly yet warm; and Jil Sander 4, a rich, spicy, early nineties number when she wanted to funk things up; on the days she wanted to be more aerated and floral, she allegedly wore Fleurissimo, but so, probably, did Queen Nefertiti, seeing that the house of Creed was launched roughly around the year 1365 BC.

Diana, true to the demure image she gave off – I forgot to say, sorry Kristen, you were great, but have you seen Australian Elizabeth Debicki as Diana in the last series of the Crown? She was taller than Di was – ok, shave her shins off! – but the acting, the accent, my god, how could someone do it THAT perfectly? – her whole dememenour was off the charts jaw-droppingly good, in a way that you felt you were actually watching Diana, rather than an impressionistic ‘capturing’; no, I was saying , sorry, re Diana’s butter wouldn’t melt initial aura, that she also went intentionally for the publically demure in her scenting, favouring Penhaligons’ Bluebell for daywear, which Thatcher also wore, presumably plagiarizing the-then-queen-to-be’s scent in an attempt to give her a whiff of humanity; she also wore Houbigant’s Quelque Fleurs, which is a pretty little number, and for warmer moments Hermès Faubourg 24, which my mum wears and gets complimented on, as well as the devastatingly lovely Van Cleef & Arpels’s First – her actual signature.

Perfume-wise, Callas went somewhere in between, classic and sophisticated, but favouring the rose/jasmine/sandalwood safe comfort zone of Chanel No 5 – can’t go wrong with that – and the cooler, but similar- Detchema De Revillon (ditto). Intriguingly, she is also said to have used Luchino Visconti’s favourite perfume, Hammam Bouquet, quite a dirty, androgynously powder pressed – a definite hint of perspiration – rose, iris and sandalwood perfume; it has its angelic aspects, but the fact that it was based on the Turkish Baths at Jermyn Street tells us quite a lot about its probable, far more sensual, origins. Maria Callas, once her eyesight was failing, would apparently leave Hammam-Drenched handkerchiefs on the stage, in the precise places she needed to be during that night’s opera, led to her arias by her perfume.

I am presuming that both Pablo Larrain, and Angelina Jolie, have tried dousing up the props and the curtains with Hammam Bouquet to give some veritas to the proceedings of Maria ; the trailers I have seen leave me deeply stiffening and cringeing (as do the pictures I have put up above; to me she just feels instinctively, disastrously not the girl.) I just can’t place Callas and Jolie together, at all. But at the same time, I am not Pablo Larrain, who is an aesthetic virtuoso, and I do like to be proven wrong; the first two films took a little getting used to before I could try to sink into their luxuriant textures, so perhaps this one will do too – if I don’t choke to death in horror on my popcorn; part of me is definitely intrigued by how all of this indulgence and majesticity pans out on screen (things take longer to get on Netflix and in cinemas than they do wherever you are) so I would love to hear your personal insights on any of the points shared above if you have already seen it and to hear that I am mistaken. Is it good? Is it terrible? Just middling? What’s your take? If you are not a cinephile, then let’s talk about the divas’ scents instead, or insights into their lives. But if any of you were in raptures watching ‘Maria’ and recommend it in any shape or form – even the apartments in Paris, etc, the mood, because I can be easily swayed by convincing and instinctual, not prissy – and particularly CGI – production design – we saw Gladiator II at the cinema on my birthday and it was as persuasive as a giant set of lego; like Angelina Jolie, who was apparently terrified to the core of taking on a singing role, and this part specificially, but took it anyway because of her fear, I just might take the plunge.

25 Comments

Filed under Flowers

25 responses to “maria / angelina

  1. OnWingsofSaffron

    I completely agree. The very second I saw the photos and the anouncement I thought: I‘m not watching that! Not in a nasty, hissy way. It‘s just I have „lived“ with her art for over 40 years, I just don‘t—in anyway—see/hear Jolie as Callas. I was just in no way emotinally touched. However that is the very essence of Callas: being touched, bowled over, put off, love, hate. So if I‘m not viscerally touched, then it is not Callas.
    Apart from the opera queen in me rejecting this, Jolie for me is Anglosaxon. Yet Callas is the embodiment of the Mediterranean—more „Roman“, piu generosa, more vulgar, zaftiger, extroverter, noisier, more (melo)drama: everything con slancio.
    In this sense, Fanny Ardant and, especially, Marina Abramović are more suited to the persona/rôle of Callas.
    Still, if the movie manages to ignite an passing interest or appetite for opera: hooray!

    • YES : the ethnicity is definitely wrong – but at least we didn’t get dark foundation and a prosthetic : I will never forgive or get over ‘Virginia Woolf’s Nose’ – which had top billing – in The Hours.

      Did you see Spencer perchance ? I found it to be a sliver of painful delight

      But you are a real opera person – I have only been three times in my life but do enjoy the odd snippet now and again :: plus like so many gay boys of a certain age I adore camp, in a myriad of (non moronic) forms

      I think if you were to be subjected to Maria in a cinema, your ears and eyes and brain would soon starting bleeding and your head would actually explode at an impactful moment of coloratura

  2. Richard Potter

    This retired opera singer enjoyed the film very much and feels Jolie did an absolutely exceptional job. She pretty well nailed the speech patterns and mannerisms, and I think the way they electronically blended the two singing voices (Maria/Angelina) was remarkably successful. I did hate Kodi Smith-McPhee’s imaginary interviewer character.

    • Oh they had to put one of those in? I didn’t need a toothless Jude Law in Contagion for that reason – a real irritant.

      Glad you enjoyed it, but what you say here about nailing the speech patterns and mannerisms, is the problem for me with biopics, to me they are often, in a way, just a form of ‘advanced mimicry’ – not actual acting from the heart. But I kind of got into Austin as Elvis as the film went on, so maybe I will get into Angelina. If she is this good, I need to see it. Usually she is just playing a version of herself,though (or how I imagine her to be). Overall, she comes across pretty humourless as an actress and a person. I wonder if she is different in real life?

    • PS I would love to know what life as an opera singer is/was like. Does the pleasure and gloriousness outweigh the stress ?

      One of my very hen-pecked Japanese colleagues is married to one and she definitely calls the shots but gets stressed out of her mind raising kids.

    • Speaking of KSMcPhee, he has a most curious face but The Power Of The Dog left me utterly cold. I don’t know if Benedict’s accent was good or not – it seemed a bit overboiled for my personal tastes and I could NOT understand the fuss that Campion film was getting when she has made so many other amazing ones.

      In The Cut, for example, is in my view a shockingly underrated sensual masterpiece. Bravo Meg Ryan – I didn’t quite get how good she can be until I saw that. Usually her hairstyle has the top billing

  3. Gregory

    She put a lot of work into this. The only aversion I have is that all movies about classical musicians and composers get botched in some way. Whether it’s Julie Andrew’s trying to look like she’s playing the violin, or the dreadful Chevalier — his music barely made the soundtrack. Jolie is an artist who clearly cared about this project, even if the writing didn’t serve its subject.

    • A tedious screenplay ?

    • I thought Todd Field’s Tar was vastly overrated too myself. Cate looked good in her designer suits but I didn’t believe a second of it.

      I suppose Geoffrey Rush was convincing in Shine.

    • I thought Hilary and Jackie had power as well

      • Gregory

        Hilary and Jackie was great. As far as screenplays go, these are often written by non-musicians who write grandiose and inaccurate statements about art, music, and what it means to be a professional musician. “I want to go out, I want to be admired!” It’s doubtful Callas would have ever expressed a sentiment like that. Artists want recognition for their work, not for who they are. This sort of thing just shows a writer doesn’t really understand the subject.

        The other thing that writers get wrong is context. In Maestro, we are never shown how or why Bernstein was important, or the influence he had on American culture. It worked for people who already knew who he was, but not a general audience. In H&J, to my recollection, it’s not really clear that Jacqueline du Pre’s career was as brief as it was. Tar never really divulged how women are treated by the classical music industry — they are still referred to as female conductors or female composers, and very few women are hired to lead orchestras largely because of systemic sexism. So her fall is only partly understandable, given that for decades men had gotten away with worse. But you had to be aware of this to really get the film.

        I could be wrong about all of this. I have been know to nod off during movies.

      • No opinion is wrong when it comes to cinema

        I was so repelled by Maestro – UGH !!!!- much as I admire Bernstein – that I had to turn it off after 15 minutes – the fake nose, for a start, just so insulting : and the chemistry between Bradley and Carey was even faker. Utterly intolerable

  4. An excellent read as always: “Anderson’s wheezing, sidewalking hairsprayed crustacean impression ofThatcher” Brilliantly funny description!

    I’d heard of the Callas film, my mum and I were thinking of going to see it, so I just had a look at the trailer and I can’t even get through that never mind the film! I also admire Jolie as an actress but in this role where you expect something of Callas, she looks somehow flat and bloodless compared to Callas. I’d almost prefer Lady Gaga in the role, hah!

    Elizabeth Debinki in the Crown was almost supernatural, it was more than mimicry. I bloody loved that series too! Maybe my favourite episode was the one where Sutherland painted Churchill – John Lithgow’s face when Sutherland gets under his skin about the pond was so awful but moving.

    My favourite TV this year has been Season 2 of Wolf Hall. Have you watched it? I’m mesmerised by Rylance’s acting. I’m so obsessed with medieval style I ordered ‘Boleyn Tudor Rose’ by Juliet Rose. It’s extremely rosy but not Pou pourri like as I’d hoped.I want to smell like a perfumed Tudor mansion but my partner says it just smells like soap on steroids. Any tips on a medieval-esque rose?!

    I’m off now to your post about Sacre Bleu to add the link you asked for to those paintings I mentioned, thanks for your interest in them!

    Thank you also for all the fascinating info about the perfumes worn by Callas. Such a good read as I lie in bed with another cold!

    • Ugh you too – o dai ji ni – I am myself coughing with bronchitis – anything respiratory freaks me out

      Delighted you love Elizabeth Debicki as Diana – supernatural is a brilliant way of putting it. I could hardly believe what I was seeing and hearing. IMPOSSIBLY good.

      Hilarious that you also couldn’t past the trailer for Maria – can you pinpoint what it is exactly that is so offputting ? ( I also thought Gaga this morning as well.. but much as I love her that would have been a travesty – instead I thought she was ravishing in Joker Folie A Deux which I saw on the big screen this year – you couldn’t take your eyes off her)

      We only have Netflix – if Wolf Hall is on Netflix I will check it out although I am definitely less attracted to the Medieval than you are – very glad I was born in 1970.

      That said, a medieval rose sounds nice. Roses… so few are satisfying in perfumery, as you know. I am going to put up a piece on some I smelled the other day – none hit the mark.

      The closest I can imagine is layering Santa Maria Novella Rosa and Pot Pourri (the perfume), which I always think is weirdly compelling

      Have any roses come close ?

      • Sorry you’re suffering with respiratory troubles too. I hate when a cold gets chesty.

        Callas had a very dramatic stillness and grace. Jolie’s gestures looked contrived in the clip, overly conscious or something like that . The mannerisms I picked up in the trailer suggested narcissism, which a diva like Callas would perhaps have, yet she also had that quality of a contained panther, if you know what I mean? Almost dangerous or feral. I feel that Jolie has great depth of emotion, but she’s far softer than Callas. It sounds like Jolie did an impressive level of voice training for the role though, so it should look convincing when she sings but according to one review it’s not.

        I love certain operas, and opera singers. I sing a lot myself and have been getting lessons from a voice coach for the last year because the female voice changes a lot in the 50s. I’m not a performer though, I just like being able to sing a bit. So if course I’m fascinated by this film. I might watch it at home when it’s out.

        Roses, hmm, Fille de Berlin is good as a medieval rose, but it lacks warmth. I have SMN Rosa Nova Aqua Colonia, never tried Rosa. I’ll have an explore of that!

        If you’re not into the Medieval aesthetic, Wolf Hall won’t appeal so much, though it’s such good acting!

      • I would like to be drawn into a convincing medieval aesthetic though … I think I was too affected by all the torture we learned about in history lessons ( one of my most hated subjects – it repelled me ); I remember the loathing I felt being taken through the dungeons on Warwick Castle, half an hour from where I’m from.

        Maybe in a past life …

      • Rosa is a bit flat yet bosomy- but the sourness of the Pot Pourri cologne is spiced and bizarre :

        incidentally I think I conjured you up : today I wore Armani but the previous days woke up with a desire for Miss Balmain vintage extrait

        Perfect for personal marination

    • Not medieval either but a fantastic rose I would love to find again ( in vintage)

      https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Loewe/L-de-Loewe-22797.html

Leave a Reply to OnWingsofSaffronCancel reply